Idaho Dairy Producers Reduce Herds Amid Plummeting Milk Prices
Source: DairyNews.today
In the heart of Idaho’s dairy country, producers like Ralph Anderson are grappling with difficult choices as milk prices continue to decline. Anderson, who once managed a thriving herd of 600 Holstein cows at his Magic Valley Farm, has drastically reduced his operation. Today, only 60 cows remain, a stark reflection of the financial pressures facing the dairy industry across the state and nation.
The downturn in milk prices has hit Idaho particularly hard, a state that has seen rapid growth in dairy production over the past decade, transforming its agricultural economy from a focus on crops like potatoes and grains to a strong emphasis on livestock and dairy. This shift made the Magic Valley region the epicenter of the state’s agricultural economy. However, the recent economic challenges have caused dairy prices to plummet by 44%, leaving many farmers with little choice but to reduce their herds and cut their losses.
Anderson, 51, who began his dairy operation with his father and brother in 1987, is now considering whether to leave the industry entirely or slowly rebuild his herd in anticipation of a potential market recovery. "Right now, the fewer cows you have, the less money you're losing," Anderson remarked, highlighting the difficult position many dairy farmers find themselves in.
The decline in milk prices has had a ripple effect on Idaho's economy. In 2008, dairy accounted for 34% of the state's total farm cash receipts, amounting to $2.153 billion. However, the recent price drop has resulted in roughly $200 million in lost revenue and taxes, according to Bob Naerebout, President of the Idaho Dairymen’s Association. Naerebout noted that the industry’s fortunes are closely tied to the strength of the national economy, which has seen fewer consumers purchasing milk and dairy products in recent months.
Dairy producers are now faced with two unenviable choices: reduce the number of animals in their herds or dispose of excess milk. This situation is particularly dire for long-time producers like Jack Davis, a second-generation dairyman in Kuna, Idaho. Davis, 62, is currently losing approximately $80,000 a month on his herd of 700 cows, a financial strain that has forced him to negotiate partial payments with his creditors. “Could you pay all of your bills if your paycheck got cut in half?” Davis asked, underscoring the gravity of the situation.
In response to the crisis, the dairy industry has taken proactive steps through the National Milk Producers Federation’s buyout program, which has shifted over 275,000 dairy cows into the beef industry over the past five years. The program, funded by a 10-cent surcharge on every hundred pounds of milk produced by its members, is seen as a necessary measure to reduce the oversupply and stabilize prices. Despite these efforts, industry experts like Scott Brown, an agricultural economist at the University of Missouri, caution that the cooperative’s actions alone may not be sufficient to address the underlying issues.
The decision to continue the herd buyout program for another two years reflects the ongoing challenges facing the industry. As dairy farmers across Idaho and the nation weigh their options, the future of the industry remains uncertain, with many producers being forced to exit the business to preserve what remains of their livelihoods.
Anderson, 51, who began his dairy operation with his father and brother in 1987, is now considering whether to leave the industry entirely or slowly rebuild his herd in anticipation of a potential market recovery. "Right now, the fewer cows you have, the less money you're losing," Anderson remarked, highlighting the difficult position many dairy farmers find themselves in.
The decline in milk prices has had a ripple effect on Idaho's economy. In 2008, dairy accounted for 34% of the state's total farm cash receipts, amounting to $2.153 billion. However, the recent price drop has resulted in roughly $200 million in lost revenue and taxes, according to Bob Naerebout, President of the Idaho Dairymen’s Association. Naerebout noted that the industry’s fortunes are closely tied to the strength of the national economy, which has seen fewer consumers purchasing milk and dairy products in recent months.
Dairy producers are now faced with two unenviable choices: reduce the number of animals in their herds or dispose of excess milk. This situation is particularly dire for long-time producers like Jack Davis, a second-generation dairyman in Kuna, Idaho. Davis, 62, is currently losing approximately $80,000 a month on his herd of 700 cows, a financial strain that has forced him to negotiate partial payments with his creditors. “Could you pay all of your bills if your paycheck got cut in half?” Davis asked, underscoring the gravity of the situation.
In response to the crisis, the dairy industry has taken proactive steps through the National Milk Producers Federation’s buyout program, which has shifted over 275,000 dairy cows into the beef industry over the past five years. The program, funded by a 10-cent surcharge on every hundred pounds of milk produced by its members, is seen as a necessary measure to reduce the oversupply and stabilize prices. Despite these efforts, industry experts like Scott Brown, an agricultural economist at the University of Missouri, caution that the cooperative’s actions alone may not be sufficient to address the underlying issues.
The decision to continue the herd buyout program for another two years reflects the ongoing challenges facing the industry. As dairy farmers across Idaho and the nation weigh their options, the future of the industry remains uncertain, with many producers being forced to exit the business to preserve what remains of their livelihoods.
23.09.2024
Carbon emissions in global milk production - the elephant in the room
I have been thinking to make this post yes/ no. I decided for yes and like to ask everyone to not "shoot the messenger". The chart shows an analysis of IFCN Dairy Research Network from the 2024 supporter conference in Poland.
